CENTER FOR THE PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION OF TEACHERS
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Our Team
    • Our Partnerships
    • Our Authors
    • Principles of Practice
    • Job Opportunities
  • What We Do
    • Services
    • Equity in Action
    • Literacy Unbound Summer Institute
    • Signature Initiatives >
      • Literacy Unbound
      • New Teacher Network
      • Student Press Initiative
  • Educator Essentials
    • Book of the month
    • Online Courses
    • Professional Articles
    • Ready-to-use Resources
    • Teaching Today Podcast
  • Support CPET

4/23/2021

Using Data to Promote Productive Struggle

Comments

Observing student behavior and communication to inform our instruction and create meaningful learning opportunities.
Picture
DR. CRISTINA COMPTON
Director of Program Development

​​
Productive struggle, a term that has gained popularity over the last decade, is found in instruction that “stretches students’ thinking and performance just beyond the level they can do on their own — the zone of proximal development.” 

Finding and teaching to each of our students’ sweet spots is no easy feat. As teachers, we are often guilty of over-scaffolding, or rescuing our students out of fear or our desire to avoid student discomfort. Alternatively, we sometimes push students too far by introducing a task that is well beyond their level, without also providing the necessary tools or assistance they need to meet the challenge. In order to support students in productive struggle, we need to be patient, persistent, and committed in gathering and using data in our instruction. This can include quantitative data such as reading levels and test scores, or perhaps more importantly, student actions and behaviors — what we know as qualitative data.

How can we gather qualitative data about our students in order to support them in finding a meaningful, productive level of struggle in their learning?  

Identifying zones of struggle
 
Before we can locate promising practices for our instruction, we first need to identify look fors and listen fors that can help us determine if and when students are being pushed too far, or are not being pushed enough.

When students are not being challenged enough or instruction is below their level, we consider this a level of no struggle. At the other end of the spectrum is destructive struggle, in which tasks are too challenging for particular students, or are significantly above their level. A zone of productive struggle lies between the two. 
Picture
Let’s identify the look fors and listen fors for each of these zones:

When students are in a no struggle zone, it might look like and sound like:
  • Finishing quickly and having nothing to do
  • Statements like, “This is kid stuff,” or “This is super easy.” 
 
When it comes to the destructive struggle zone, we might observe students who: 
  • Don’t get started on a task
  • Chat, stare off into space, or other exhibit other off-task behaviors
  • Communicate things like: “This is boring,” or “I don’t know what to do,” or even “I’m not doing this!”
 
In contrast, when students are in a zone of productive struggle, we are likely to see them:
  • Work for a bit, maybe ask a question or two, and then ask for help
  • Share statements like: “I think I get it, but can you help me with…”

Observing student behavior online

​Given that so much instruction is happening remotely, and we may not be able to observe the same behaviors from our students in a remote setting, we can also identify look fors and listen fors when online teaching and learning is taking place. 

 
In a no struggle zone, we might observe online students who are: 
  • Clearly engaged in another window, program, or activity
  • Finished quickly and starting to engage in another task at home
  • Talking and unmuting themselves before others are finished, causing distractions
 
When students are in a place of destructive struggle online, they might: 
  • Turn off their cameras
  • Leave the call
  • Never unmute themselves or share their voice
  • Yell, get frustrated, or even cry, depending on the age of the student
 
In contrast, productive struggle might look and sound like:
  • Students who are able to get started on their work on their own — whether that means they are typing into a Google slide, a Padlet, or a Jamboard. You are able to see evidence of their work. 
  • Students who have their camera on, and use the chat feature and/or unmute themselves to engage in conversation, ask questions, or clarify the task
 
Determining students’ current zones of struggle is a helpful starting point for potential shifts in your instruction. Different students at different times might exhibit these behaviors, and this can inform your responses and course of action. By leaning on these look fors and listen fors, we can more effectively and confidently determine if, when, and how many scaffolds need to be introduced so that students are advancing their skills.

Preemptive planning
 
In addition to locating student behaviors and communication that can surface as they’re working on tasks, we can also lean on preemptive planning, which will support us in predicting and creating opportunities for productive struggle in our classrooms. Preemptive planning encourages thoughtful consideration and analysis of each task we’re offering students — whether it’s a culminating task of a unit or a task for a particular lesson. This process involves asking questions such as:

  • What will students need to know and be able to do when it comes to this task?
  • What are the prior knowledge demands that this task requires?
  • Where and how do I think my students might struggle?
  • Where and how do I think they might do well?
  • Based on this analysis, what are some instructional strategies I should teach?
 
These questions can inform your instructional design as you work to meet the individual needs of students. Your assessment of students’ areas of struggle can inform where and how you’ll need to scaffold your instruction, and the areas of strength can inform where and how you introduce extensions or opportunities for deeper learning.

Similar to identifying and responding to look fors and listen fors, preemptive planning is a meaningful form of data collection that can help you predict or anticipate student performance and ultimately use these predictions to inspire, inform, and cater your planning and instruction to your students. 

​There is no denying the challenges involved in meeting students where they are, especially when teaching large numbers of students — many of whom are on vastly different levels — or teaching at a distance. But by engaging in strategic planning based on data and evidence, we can create opportunities for our students to challenge themselves, recognize that they can do hard things, and make progress in their learning.  
​
Picture
Picture
DESIGNING BLENDED INSTRUCTION
Picture
STUDENT BEHAVIOR AS DATA
Picture
DATA OBSERVATION & INTERPRETATION
Comments
    ←  BACK TO ALL ARTICLES

    Picture
    SEARCH BY TOPIC
    21st century skills
    Adult learning
    Assessment & testing
    Classroom culture & SEL
    Classroom management
    CRSE / CRSP
    Curriculum
    Data-driven instruction
    Growth & goals
    Leadership & teams
    Literacy
    Project-based learning
    Rigorous instruction
    Student engagement

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Picture
    Get started
Picture
The Center for Professional Education of Teachers (CPET) at Teachers College, Columbia University is committed to making excellent and equitable education accessible worldwide. ​CPET unites theory and practice to promote transformational change. We design innovative projects, cultivate sustainable partnerships, and conduct research through direct and online services to youth and educators. Grounded in adult learning theories, our six core principles structure our customized approach and expand the capacities of educators around the world.

ABOUT US

525 West 120th Street, Box 182
New York, NY 10027
​416 Zankel

Ph: (212) 678-3161
[email protected]

Our Team
Career Opportunities
EDUCATOR RESOURCES

Book of the Month
Online Courses
Professional Articles
Ready-to-Use Resources
Teaching Today Podcast
COACHING SERVICES

Custom Coaching
Global Learning Alliance
Literacy Unbound
​New Teacher Network
Student Press Initiative
MAKE A DIFFERENCE

​​Every gift is an investment in equitable education. With your support, we can continue to bring transformative change for K-12 teachers, leaders, and students worldwide. 
Donate

  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Our Team
    • Our Partnerships
    • Our Authors
    • Principles of Practice
    • Job Opportunities
  • What We Do
    • Services
    • Equity in Action
    • Literacy Unbound Summer Institute
    • Signature Initiatives >
      • Literacy Unbound
      • New Teacher Network
      • Student Press Initiative
  • Educator Essentials
    • Book of the month
    • Online Courses
    • Professional Articles
    • Ready-to-use Resources
    • Teaching Today Podcast
  • Support CPET